Comparison Reviews: Quicken Loans Rates vs. Citibank Mortgage Rates vs. PNC Mortgage Rates

Taking out a mortgage for your personal home purchase can be both exciting and stressful. For most people, they will be maintaining their mortgage for the next three decades, which can add up to a lot of money paid in interest.

Therefore, choosing the right lender is key to helping you make wise financial decisions for your future. How do you know whether or not you’re getting the best rates?

Many people can identify several of the top names when it comes to mortgage lenders: Citibank, Quicken Loans, and PNC Bank. But how do Quicken Loans rates, PNC mortgage rates, and Citibank mortgage rates compare? In a detailed, side-by-side comparison, AdvisoryHQ wants to help you determine which (if any) of these lenders is the right choice.

Find out who has the lowest rates and the best reviews. Will it be the Quicken Loans rates, PNC mortgage rates or Citibank mortgage rates? It’s time to uncover the truth.

See Also: Home Interest Rates | Tips for Finding the Best Home Mortgage Interest Rates

Changing Mortgage Rates

You’ve probably heard lenders advertise that their mortgage rates are at an all-time low, but do you know how long they’ll stay there?

The truth is that any of the Quicken Loans rates, PNC Bank mortgage rates or CitiMortgage rates could change as soon as tomorrow. The market is in a constant state of flux, and mortgage rates are highly affected by changes that could have nothing to do with the mortgage market.

Which factors can you expect to have the biggest impact on Quicken Loans mortgage rates or those from any other company? Lenders frequently change their interest rates based on indicators within the economy as a whole.

Economic growth or slowdown can prompt a shift in either direction as can the forecasts that economists make about future movement. Even the country’s money supply can alter the PNC mortgage rates or Citibank mortgage rates.

quicken loans rates

Image source: Pixabay

To sum it up, there is an almost endless outside influence for what can affect Quicken mortgage rates, PNC mortgage rates, and Citibank mortgage rates. We aim to be able to demonstrate exactly how each company stands against the others based on the rates we uncover today. However, bear in mind that these rates could change at any time.

When you’re comparing mortgage rates, you should always do your best to make those comparisons in the same time period so they aren’t as susceptible to the influence of fluctuations in the market.

If possible, your side-by-side comparison of all lenders you are potentially interested in should occur on the same day. Comparing the Quicken Loans rates, PNC mortgage rates, and Citibank mortgage rates side by side should occur on a very close timetable.

Don’t Miss: Citi® Double Cash Card vs. BankAmericard Cash Rewards™ vs. Spark Cash Select vs. Blue Cash Everyday® Card

Quicken Loans Rates

Quicken Loans is recognized as one of the biggest players in the field of online lenders when it comes to mortgages. Consumers are becoming more interested in the convenience and accessibility of performing their financing via the Internet, without the face-to-face interactions involved with traditional financial institutions. What’s more, the anonymity of the process hasn’t decreased any of the customer satisfaction ratings surrounding the company or the Quicken Loans rates.

According to a collection of consumer reviews from Credit Karma, Quicken Loans was rated with 4.4 stars (out of a possible total of 5) with input from 674 reviews. Of those ratings, at least 75 percent of them gave Quicken Loans the highest possible rating.

The company promises a number of potential loan choices for your mortgage, ranging from federal programs, such as loans through the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Federal Housing Administration, to jumbo loans. More traditional options include both 30-year and 15-year fixed-rate mortgages as well as adjustable-rate mortgages.

Online lenders have long been promising some of the lowest rates in the industry due to a lessened overhead from not having to maintain brick-and-mortar locations. How do the Quicken Loans mortgage rates compare to others in the mortgage industry?

In our recent comparison, as of October 21, 2016, its rates were fairly competitive with well-known traditional financial institutions. The Quicken Loans mortgage rates for its most popular selection, the 30-year fixed-rate mortgage, came in at 3.5 percent. To cut that fixed-rate mortgage in half, to just a 15-year loan term, the Quicken Loans rate gives you a significant reduction as well, at 2.75 percent.

The rates are similar for an adjustable-rate mortgage as well. When it comes to a 5/1 ARM, you can count on a 2.75 percent Quicken Loans rate.

All-in-One Change Management Tools

Top Rated Toolkit for Change Managers.

Get Your Change Management Tool Today...

Citibank Mortgage Rates

Citibank mortgage options offer all of the same benefits of an online lender such as Quicken Loans. It features a well-detailed education center with articles surrounding factors that affect your Citibank mortgage rates (think credit score and debt-to-income ratio) as well as the hidden costs of a home mortgage. Citibank is nothing if not thorough when it comes to providing consumers with the education they need to make wise investment decisions for their future.

Where CitiMortgage shines is in the opportunity for consumers to apply for a mortgage at one of its branch locations if they prefer the traditional method of meeting with a representative face to face. You can also utilize its customer service hotline or online application to receive a prequalification instead. The biggest complaint among consumers seems to be the application fee, as most lenders do not charge one at all.

Citibank loans come in a variety of shapes and sizes, from a thirty-year fixed-rate mortgage to Citibank loans for home equity or refinancing. Like with most mortgage lenders, CitiMortgage provides almost every type of loan imaginable: 30-year fixed rate loans (along with 20-year, 15-year, and 10-year options) and adjustable-rate mortgages ranging from 3/1 to 10/1.

Curious how the CitiMortgage rates compare to other top lenders in the industry? Let’s take a look at its base rates when it comes to typical Citibank mortgage rates. For the purposes of our research, we are going to compare the two most popular fixed-rate mortgages (30-year and 15-year terms) and a 5/1 ARM.

The Citibank mortgage rates for a 30-year loan term are very competitive with similar lenders including Quicken Loans rates. CitiMortgage advertises a 3.5 percent interest rate on a 30-year loan with a slight discount for a 15-year loan term (Citibank mortgage rates on a 15-year loan term are only at 2.75 percent).

When it comes to adjustable-rate mortgages, a 5/1 ARM has a slightly higher Citibank mortgage rate in our own findings than the Quicken Loans rates. It is advertised at an even 3 percent compared to several lenders who come in just slightly lower.

Related: How to Find the Highest Savings Account Rates | This Year’s Guide | Highest Savings 

PNC Mortgage Rates

According to consumer reviews, PNC Bank, as a whole, is a pretty well-recognized financial institution. With a collection of more than 2,000 user reviews, LendingTree has bestowed it a four out of five-star rating and an 85 percent recommendation rate. This bodes well for consumers interested in its services. In its separate breakdown detailing PNC Bank mortgage rates, it received the same four-star rating.

From applying online to managing your mortgage payments, everything about PNC Bank’s website is designed to simplify the process. PNC Bank mortgage rates encompass an array of loan options for the more traditional fixed-rate mortgage to adjustable-rate mortgages as well as jumbo loans, FHA loans, VA loans, and combination loans. There’s no shortage of financing options from the PNC Bank mortgage rates.

How do PNC mortgage rates stack up against the two competitors we’re reviewing? We’re going to take a closer look at the PNC mortgage rates in the following section to determine whether they’re competitive with other popular lenders in the same arena.

pnc mortgage rates

Source: PNC Mortgage Rates

On a 30-year fixed-rate loan, the PNC mortgage rates are surprising low, at just 3.375 percent. This certainly beats out the Quicken mortgage rates and the CitiMortgage rates rather quickly. Moving on to a 15-year term, we see the same pattern. The Quicken mortgage rates and CitiMortgage rates were equal, at 2.75 percent, but the PNC mortgage rates come in at just 2.5 percent overall.

However, the PNC mortgage rates are right in line with their competitors when it comes to adjustable-rate mortgages. They match the low Quicken Loans rates of just 2.75 percent for a 5/1 ARM.

Popular Article: Mortgage Interest Rates Trend | Key Mortgage Rate Predictions, Trends, and 

Refinancing Options

We’ve taken a brief look at the overall direction that the Quicken Loans rates, Citibank mortgage rates, and PNC mortgage rates are headed in. However, we have yet to touch on a very important service that all of these lenders offer: refinancing. All three of our major competitors also offer this to those who already own a home, so we need to take another look at the CitiMortgage, PNC Bank, and Quicken Loans refinance rates.

citibank mortgage rates

Source: Quicken Loans Mortgage Calculator

To simplify things, we’ve created the table below, displaying the information and current rates for a variety of refinancing options among the three lenders. We compiled the data for the same types of refinancing that we did for the initial purchase of a new home in order to accurately assess and compare products. Let’s see how the three of our competitors fared against one another:

Mortgage Type

Quicken Loans Refinance Rate

CitiMortgage Refinance Rate

PNC Bank Refinance Rate

30-Year Fixed Rate3.5%3.625%3.5%
15-Year Fixed RateNot available2.875%2.75%
5/1 ARM2.99%3.25%2.875%

As you can clearly tell, the Quicken Loans refinance rates are significantly lower than that of Citibank loans for refinancing. Overall, the PNC mortgage rates for refinancing come in lower than both the Quicken Loans rates and Citibank mortgage rates, making it the clear winner for this category.

The PNC mortgage rates for refinancing match the Quicken Loans rates for a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage but are slightly lower in every other category. When it comes to adjustable-rate mortgages and refinancing, its 5/1 ARM has a substantial savings over the Citibank mortgage rates (0.375 percent difference).

The disadvantage to this comparison was our inability to recover the 15-year fixed-rate Quicken Loans rates. However, based on all of our other data, we can assume that the Quicken Loans rates are likely very similar to those offered by Citibank mortgage rates. The difference between the Citibank mortgage rates and PNC mortgage rates in this category was slight but still significant, with Citibank mortgage rates being higher by just 0.125 percent.

Overall Comparison

In order to make the comparison between the three lenders easier to see, we’ve compiled the data from all three into this side-by-side comparison. Take a look at how the rates compare when you can see them all in one place:

Mortgage Type

Quicken Loans Mortgage Rates

Citibank Mortgage Rates

PNC Mortgage Rates

30-Year Fixed Rate3.5%3.5%3.375%
15-Year Fixed Rate2.75%2.75%2.5%
5/1 ARM2.75%3.0%2.75%

Clearly, the Quicken Loans rates and Citibank mortgage rates are likely to be right in line with one another when it comes to fixed-rate mortgages. Between the two lenders, you’re likely to receive almost identical rates when you input the same information regarding your personal financial situation.

PNC mortgage rates still beat both companies when it comes to fixed-rate mortgages. On its adjustable-rate mortgages, it is an even tie with the Quicken Loans rates, both which were 0.25 percent lower than the Citibank mortgage rates.

When it comes to refinancing, it appears that the PNC mortgage rates were the lowest. Even without the addition of the 15-year fixed-rate refinancing from the Quicken Loans rates, it appears that the PNC mortgage rates for refinancing were equal to or less than both Quicken Loans rates and Citibank mortgage rates in every category.

The verdict is in. If you’re searching for a mortgage company based on the rates alone, we would have to say that the data suggests that PNC mortgage rates are most likely the lowest of these three companies.


Purchasing a new home and taking out a mortgage is a long-term commitment to a particular lender. You want to be certain that you’re receiving the best possible rates, so it makes sense that you want to compare them side by side.

The Quicken Loans rates, PNC mortgage rates, and Citibank mortgage rates all come in fairly close to one another, but, overall, we would deem PNC mortgage rates as the winner.

However, there’s more to a mortgage than just the interest rates. Be sure that you have a good conversation with any lender that you are interested in financing through.

You want to also be certain that you are satisfied with its customer service and knowledge of the mortgage process. After all, you’ll be with this lender for as many as thirty years.

AdvisoryHQ wants you to be able to make a wise and sound financial decision when it comes to your mortgage. We hope that this thorough comparison of Quicken Loans rates, PNC mortgage rates, and Citibank mortgage rates will help you to do just that.

Read More: Top Best Credit Unions Credit Cards | Ranking | Best CU Secured & Unsecured Credit Card Offers

AdvisoryHQ (AHQ) Disclaimer:

Reasonable efforts have been made by AdvisoryHQ to present accurate information, however all info is presented without warranty. Review AdvisoryHQ’s Terms for details. Also review each firm’s site for the most updated data, rates and info.

Note: Firms and products, including the one(s) reviewed above, may be AdvisoryHQ's affiliates. Click to view AdvisoryHQ's advertiser disclosures.